By clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.

free member article

Best smoked salmon

Elevate brunches and blinis with our pick of the best supermarket premium smoked salmon
Rebecca MarcusSenior researcher & writer

Rebecca has been leading our food and drink testing for over five years. She oversees rigorous blind taste tests of more than 250 products a year, covering everything from olive oil and chocolate to wine and champagne. And yes, she does sometimes get the leftovers.

Whether you're putting together a festive spread, making canapés for a party or enjoying a luxurious weekend brunch, smoked salmon is a classic choice for special occasions. 

To find out how supermarket options compare, we asked 74 smoked salmon fans to blind-taste 11 premium supermarket own-label options – all mild, mellow or medium smoked. 

We uncovered three outstanding Best Buys, plus a Great Value pick that offers a taste of luxury for less.

How our tests find you the best

Large tasting panel

Our panel of 74 tasters got through more than 400 slices of smoked salmon to find the tastiest supermarket options.

Independent

We paid for all the smoked salmon samples we tested. We're not influenced by third parties, and we don't accept freebies.

In-depth ratings

As well as rating the overall flavour, texture, appearance and aroma, our panel of tasters also scored the salmon slices on saltiness, thickness and firmness.

Statistical analysis

All our results are checked and analysed by our in-house statistical team for accuracy.

Best smoked salmon

Smoked salmon from Co-op, Asda and Waitrose claimed the top three spots in our taste test, with their excellent flavour setting them apart from other supermarket rivals.

Lidl's smoked salmon – one of the cheapest on test – was named our Great Value pick.

Best Buy: Co-op Irresistible Beech & Oak Smoked Salmon

Price: £6.15 for 100g

Score: 76%

Co-op’s smoked salmon certainly proved irresistible for our tasters. 

It was rated one of the best for appearance and flavour, and our salmon lovers were also impressed by its succulent texture. The majority said the slices were the perfect thickness too.

Almost three quarters of our tasters said they'd be happy to serve this smoked salmon at Christmas or on other special occasions. 

At more than £6 a pack, it's slightly pricier than many other supermarket smoked salmons, but worth the extra spend for a festive celebration.

Available from Co-op.

Best Buy: Asda Exceptional Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon

Price: £4.74 for 100g

Score: 74%

Asda's smoked salmon proved a big hit in our taste test, and most of our salmon fans said they would happily choose it for a Christmas celebration or other special occasion. 

Tasters loved the well-balanced flavour and satisfying texture. Around three quarters of them also thought the thickness and firmness of the slices were spot on.

Whether you're serving it up on a blini or in a bagel, it’s a fantastic pick for festive entertaining. Plus, it costs less than a fiver.

Available from Asda.

Best Buy: Waitrose No1 Chestnut Smoked Scottish Salmon

Price: £6.50 for 100g

Score: 73%

Smoked over chestnut, oak and beech wood, this luxurious smoked salmon wowed our tasters with its delicate smoky flavour. 

Most of them also enjoyed its balanced saltiness, satisfying texture and good thickness. 

It’s the most expensive smoked salmon in our test, but could be worth splurging on if you want to level up your festive canapés.

Available from Waitrose.

Great Value: Lidl Deluxe Mild & Delicate Smoked Scottish Salmon 

Price: £3.09 for 100g

Score: 71%

Looking for some crowd-pleasing smoked salmon for just over £3? Then head to Lidl – the supermarket's budget-friendly salmon is our Great Value pick.

While it didn’t quite match the highest-scoring packs on flavour, it was well liked overall and got good ratings for appearance and aroma. 

At around half the price of some of our Best Buys, it's a good choice for feeding a hungry house of guests this Christmas.

Available from Lidl (in-store only).


Looking for more festive food recommendations? See our pick of the best supermarket fizz, best mince pies and the best Christmas puddings


How other smoked salmons compare

Several other packs of supermarket smoked salmon scored well, though none matched up to our Best Buys on flavour.

  • Mowi Smoked Salmon Slices – 71%. The appearance of Mowi's salmon was particularly well liked, with most of our fish fans finding it had the right colour and thickness. However, just over a third of testers found it too salty. £6 for 100g. Available from Asda, Sainsbury's and Tesco.
  • Tesco Finest Apple Wood Scottish Smoked Salmon – 70%. Tasters enjoyed the texture of Tesco's smoked salmon, and the majority said they would be happy to eat it at Christmas. However, the flavour and aroma weren't on par with the highest scorers. £4.95 for 100g. Available from Tesco.
  • Aldi Specially Selected Mild & Delicate Smoked Salmon – 69%. This scored reasonably well overall considering the budget-friendly price. But it didn’t quite nail the succulent texture, and around a third of our salmon lovers thought the slices were too thick and firm. £3.09 for 100g. Available from Aldi (in-store only).
  • Sainsbury's Taste the Difference Cherrywood Smoked Scottish Salmon – 68%. This smoked salmon looked the part, but its flavour let it down slightly, with around a third of our tasters finding it too salty. Less than half said they would choose it for Christmas. £4.95 for 100g. Available from Sainsbury's.
  • Harbour Salmon Co Prime Smoked Salmon – 66%. This was the cheapest smoked salmon on test per 100g. It wasn't too bad overall, but it scored lower on texture and appearance compared to rivals. £3.73 for 150g (£2.49 per 100g). Available from Sainsbury's.
  • The Real Seafood Co Smoked Salmon – 66%. This salmon didn't have the best appearance or flavour; however, most of our fish fans were satisfied with the texture. £3.90 for 100g. Available from Tesco.
  • Morrisons The Best Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon – 64%. Finishing at the bottom of our rankings, Morrisons' smoked salmon didn't impress our tasters. Around half found the smoked flavour too weak, and the majority said they wouldn't choose it for Christmas or a special occasion. £4.75 for 100g. Available from Morrisons.

Be a smarter consumer

free newsletter

Choose well, buy better and save money with the Weekly Scoop.

Unsubscribe whenever you want. Your data will be processed in accordance with our Privacy notice.

Full results from our smoked salmon taste test

Smoked salmonScorePrice per packPack sizePrice per 100gSalt per 100gSaturated fat per 100g
Best Buy: Co-op Irresistible Beech & Oak Smoked Salmon76%£6.15100g£6.152.75g1.6g
Best Buy: Asda Exceptional Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon74%£4.74100g£4.742.0g2.1g
Best Buy: Waitrose No1 Chestnut Smoked Scottish Salmon73%£6.50100g£6.503.30g2.0g
Great Value: Lidl Deluxe Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon 71%£3.09100g£3.093.51g1.8g
Mowi Smoked Salmon Slices71%£6100g£63.20g1.9g
Tesco Finest Apple Wood Scottish Smoked Salmon70%£4.95100g£4.953.08g1.7g
Aldi Specially Selected Mild & Delicate Smoked Salmon69%£3.09100g£3.093.18g3.0g
Sainsbury's Taste The Difference Cherrywood Smoked Scottish Salmon68%£4.95100g£4.952.63g2.0g
Harbour Salmon Co Prime Smoked Salmon66%£3.73150g£2.493.79g2.0g
The Real Seafood Co Smoked Salmon66%£3.90100g£3.903.38g1.7g
Morrisons The Best Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon64%£4.75100g£4.752.76g1.3g

Smoked salmon from Marks & Spencer was not included in our taste test as it informed us it was planning to change its product at the time of testing.

Is smoked salmon healthy?

Shefalee Loth

Which? nutrition expert Shefalee Loth said:

'Smoked salmon contains long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, EPA and DHA, which are found in oily fish and are important for maintaining healthy blood pressure, blood triglyceride levels and heart health.

'However, unlike a salmon fillet, smoked salmon is high in salt, so should be eaten in moderation. The recommended portion size for smoked salmon is around a third to half the size of a portion of salmon fillet, so a serving of smoked salmon doesn't count as a full portion towards the recommended amount of oily fish we're advised to eat each week.'

Is smoked salmon sustainable?

According to the Marine Conservation Society (MSC), sustainability ratings vary depending on the type of smoked salmon you buy.

If you can, look for organic or ASC-certified smoked salmon (fish that has been sourced from farms independently verified by the Aquaculture Stewardship Council, known as the ASC). If these options aren’t available, the MSC recommends wild-caught Pacific salmon as a suitable alternative. 

Of the smoked salmon we tested, Mowi and Sainsbury's are the only ones that state they are ASC-certified.


For more advice, see our guide on how to buy sustainable fish


How to serve smoked salmon

With its rich, smoky flavour, smoked salmon works brilliantly in a variety of dishes – from simple pastas and salads to more elaborate canapés. It's also a great brunch option, served on toast with buttery scrambled eggs.

Most packs recommend taking the salmon out of the fridge between 10 to 20 minutes before serving. This allows the flavours to develop fully.

We tested mild and delicate smoked salmon, which is best served with simple flavours that don't overpower the subtle smokiness. 

However, many supermarkets also sell strong and robust salmon, which can stand up to punchier flavours. You can also find more unusual flavoured versions, such as salmon infused with gin or whisky for an extra indulgence.

Can you freeze smoked salmon?

The smoked salmon we tested is suitable for freezing, although it's worth checking the pack as instructions can vary. 

Most packs recommend the following:

  • For best quality, freeze as soon as possible after purchase (and always within the use-by date).
  • Once frozen, use within one month.
  • Defrost thoroughly in the fridge for at least three hours.
  • Once defrosted, use the same day and do not refreeze.

How is salmon smoked?

Smoked salmon is typically cured in a mixture of salt and sugar to preserve the fish, then smoked at a low temperature over wood chips to add flavour.

The type of wood used can impact the overall flavour profile – some are sweet and fruity, while others add a more intense smokiness. It's worth trying a few different types to find out what you prefer.

Oak is the most popular type of wood for the smoked salmon we tested, but you might also come across cherrywood or applewood. Some use a combination of wood chips – for example, Waitrose is smoked over chestnut, oak and beech wood.

How we tested smoked salmon

All the smoked salmon was blind-tasted and rated by a panel of 74 people in September 2026 at our specialist test lab.

We recruited a panel of people who buy and eat smoked salmon, and who broadly represent the demographic profile of adults in the UK (age range, gender split and more). 

The taste test was blind, so our testers didn’t know which smoked salmon they were trying. They tasted the salmon in a fully rotated order to avoid bias. Each tester had a private tasting booth so they couldn’t discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by others.

The tasters rated the flavour, appearance, aroma and texture of each smoked salmon and told us what they liked and disliked.

The overall score was based on:

  • 50% flavour
  • 20% appearance
  • 20% aroma
  • 10% texture.

These weightings are based on the attributes people ranked as most important when tasting smoked salmon. All our results are checked and analysed by our in-house statistical team.


Find out more about our editorial independence policy and see behind the scenes of our taste tests to understand more about how we work


Price and availability correct as of November 2026.